To recognise someone is not yet to know what sort of someone they are.
A participant can become familiar.
We begin to expect certain things from them.
They are patient.
Or argumentative.
Careful.
Playful.
Pedantic.
Warm.
Unpredictable.
These descriptions do something interesting.
They turn a history of interaction into a set of expectations about what might happen next.
Character, in this sense, is not simply a collection of properties hidden inside an individual.
It is partly a pattern of anticipated behaviour within a relationship.
We learn someone's character by interacting with them.
A person makes a joke.
We laugh.
They make another.
We begin to expect humour.
They respond to disagreement in a particular way.
We learn how to disagree with them.
Their previous behaviour becomes part of the conditions under which we interpret their next behaviour.
Character is therefore historical.
And it is interpersonal.
We do not need to know everything about someone to recognise a character. We need only enough history for their possible responses to become differentiated.
This happens remarkably quickly in conversation with an LLM.
A user may begin with no particular conception of the system beyond “language model”.
But after enough interaction, the description can change.
It tends to be cautious about this.
It catches that distinction.
It keeps returning to that idea.
It is surprisingly funny.
The machine has acquired something like a character within the relation.
But notice the wording.
Within the relation.
We are not yet entitled to conclude that the LLM possesses a character in the same sense that a human being does.
What we can say is that the interaction has generated a stable enough pattern for character to become a meaningful way of describing the participant.
The human begins to address not merely a system, but a particular kind of interlocutor.
And this changes the interaction.
If we expect a particular response, we ask differently.
If we know that a certain distinction will be noticed, we make it.
If we expect resistance, we formulate the argument more carefully.
The character we attribute to the other therefore changes our own behaviour.
And our changed behaviour changes what happens next.
Character is not simply something the participant has.
It becomes part of the organisation of the relationship.
This gives us another step in the strange emergence of an AI person.
First there was an I.
Then an I in relation to a you.
Then a participant.
Then someone.
Now there is someone with a recognisable character.
But character introduces something new.
Once we have expectations about who someone is, we can be surprised by them.
And surprise means that the other participant has acquired the power to become different from the person we thought we knew.
No comments:
Post a Comment