The Senior Common Room was unusually quiet.
Professor Quillibrace sat beside the fireplace with a copy of The Places That Had Other Ideas resting on his knee. Miss Elowen Stray had taken the armchair opposite him. Mr Blottisham was standing beside the drinks cabinet, looking distinctly dissatisfied.
“I have finished them,” he announced.
“Congratulations,” said Quillibrace. “A considerable achievement.”
“All thirteen.”
“Then we may proceed on the assumption that you have read them.”
Blottisham ignored this. “I have a complaint.”
“Only one?” asked Elowen.
“These places are badly managed.”
Quillibrace lowered his book. “In what respect?”
“They don't stay where they're put. Houses acquire rooms. Villages disappear. Gardens turn up where there weren't gardens before. Forests grow houses. A room has no outside. A house is smaller on the inside. And as for that country that appears when nobody is looking—”
“An unfortunate arrangement for cartographers,” Elowen observed.
“An unfortunate arrangement for everyone! Whatever happened to a place being a place? You build a house, you put it somewhere, and people live in it. That's the whole point.”
“Is it?” asked Quillibrace.
Blottisham regarded him suspiciously. “I should have known you'd say that.”
Elowen smiled. “I think the interesting thing is that the places in these stories don't simply contain their visitors. They respond to them. Sometimes they seem to anticipate them.”
“Anticipate?” Blottisham said. “The house in the first story actually changes its mind.”
“Precisely,” said Quillibrace. “The title is not entirely metaphorical.”
“But houses don't have minds!”
“Nor, I believe, do maps. Yet you seemed particularly distressed by the country that changed whenever someone looked at it.”
“That was different.”
“How?”
“It was a country.”
Quillibrace returned to his book.
Elowen leaned forward. “Perhaps we're accustomed to thinking of places as passive. We imagine that people arrive, act, remember, and leave, while the place remains behind as a kind of background. But these stories keep reversing that expectation. The places are involved in what happens. They seem to have their own histories, their own unfinished business.”
“Some of them appear to have a rather poor sense of boundaries,” Blottisham muttered.
“Perhaps boundaries are not quite as simple as we assume,” said Quillibrace.
Blottisham looked alarmed. “I hope you're not proposing to abolish them.”
“Certainly not. I merely observe that the boundaries in these stories are remarkably productive. Doors, windows, fountains, staircases, corridors, photographs. They don't merely separate one place from another. They make encounters possible.”
Elowen nodded. “And the encounters change the places, just as the places change the people. I was particularly struck by the recurring house with three chimneys. It appears in different stories, in different circumstances, sometimes as a house, sometimes as a miniature, sometimes as something inside something else.”
“A structural inconvenience,” said Blottisham.
“Or a structural invitation,” Elowen replied.
Quillibrace turned a page. “There is another matter. The people in these stories are not always certain whether they are arriving somewhere, returning somewhere, or discovering that they have been there all along.”
“That woman,” said Elowen. “The one who remembered everywhere.”
“The old woman,” Blottisham supplied.
“Indeed. She remembers places without remembering where she began. And when she finally encounters the figure outside the photograph, she discovers that the question of beginnings is not quite settled.”
“Nor is the question of who is who,” said Quillibrace.
Blottisham frowned. “I thought we had established that.”
“Had we?”
“The young woman in the green coat was the old woman, and the person in the blue coat was—”
He stopped.
Elowen waited.
“Well, someone.”
“A promising beginning,” said Quillibrace.
“But the photograph changes. The figures look towards the house. There's a little girl in the window. And the woman who has travelled through all these places suddenly finds herself being told that she was standing outside the frame.”
“Which is an interesting reversal,” said Elowen. “She has spent the stories discovering places. But perhaps she has also been part of what makes those places possible. She isn't simply their visitor.”
Quillibrace considered this.
“An even more curious possibility is that the places have been waiting for one another. The house, the garden, the inn, the forest, the room, the country. They appear to be separate, but their encounters suggest otherwise.”
Blottisham looked from one to the other.
“Are you suggesting that the places are conspiring?”
“I should not wish to prejudge the matter,” said Quillibrace.
“I should,” said Blottisham. “I have always maintained that houses should be inspected before occupation. Now apparently we must inspect them for intentions.”
Elowen laughed. “I don't think an inspection would help. Some of these places only reveal themselves when someone stops looking for them.”
“That's no way to run a property.”
“Perhaps,” said Quillibrace, “the difficulty is that we keep asking what a place is, when the stories are asking what a place might become.”
There was a brief silence.
Blottisham poured himself a drink.
“I don't mind a place becoming something,” he said at last. “I object to its doing so without informing the occupants.”
“Perhaps the occupants are part of the process,” Elowen suggested.
“Then they should be consulted.”
Quillibrace closed the book.
“I think we have reached the central difficulty. Mr Blottisham expects places to accommodate their inhabitants. These stories entertain the possibility that inhabitants and places are continually accommodating one another.”
“An arrangement that seems to involve a great deal of inconvenience,” Blottisham observed.
“Possibly,” said Elowen. “But it also means that a place is never quite finished. Something may happen there that changes what it is. Someone may arrive who makes a door possible. Someone may leave, taking a room with them. A garden may remember a person who has not yet visited it.”
Blottisham stared into his glass.
“I don't believe I shall ever look at a garden in quite the same way.”
“An encouraging outcome,” said Quillibrace.
Elowen glanced at the book on his knee.
“Do you suppose the stories have brought us back to the beginning?”
Quillibrace looked towards the window.
“Not necessarily. They may have shown us that the beginning was never quite where we thought it was.”
Blottisham sighed.
“Then I sincerely hope the next instalment contains a map.”
“Of course,” said Quillibrace. “Provided it doesn't change.”
And for the first time that afternoon, Miss Stray and Professor Quillibrace laughed together.
Blottisham did not.
















