Social systems are already organised through relations of mattering. The activities of their participants have consequences for one another, and recurrent interactions contribute to patterns of collective organisation. These patterns may be sustained, modified or disrupted through the ongoing activities of those involved.
But social organisation also develops another capacity: the capacity to construe experience through meaning.
This is the further transition identified in Halliday's taxonomy. Physical systems acquire the organisation of life; biological systems develop social organisation through value; and social systems acquire the further organisation of semiotic systems through meaning. Each level incorporates the preceding one while introducing a new dimension of organisation.
The distinction between social value and semiotic meaning is therefore essential. Meaning is not simply a more elaborate form of mattering. Nor is it the sum of the consequences that social relationships have for their participants. It involves a different way in which significance is organised.
A social relationship may matter without being symbolically construed. The activities of participants can sustain patterns of affiliation, cooperation or dependence without those patterns being represented through language. Their interactions may be organised through embodied responses, established practices and material arrangements. Social value is already present in the consequences of these relations.
Semiotic systems introduce the capacity to construe such experience symbolically. Through language and other semiotic resources, participants can make distinctions, establish relationships, negotiate positions and develop shared interpretations of their circumstances. What happens is no longer only consequential for those involved; it can also become something that is construed and made meaningful.
This does not mean that meaning is added to an otherwise meaningless social world. The social world already matters. Semiotic organisation develops within relationships that have their own histories, consequences and conditions of continuity.
Nor does meaning simply reproduce what is already there. Semiotic systems make new forms of organisation possible. Participants can construe events that are absent, anticipate events that have not yet occurred, establish relations between otherwise separate experiences and negotiate alternative ways of understanding their circumstances. They can make aspects of social life available for reflection, discussion and transformation.
Language is especially powerful in this respect because it is not merely a system for naming things. As Halliday's account of the metafunctions shows, language simultaneously construes experience, enacts social relationships and organises these meanings into texts. Its resources enable participants to represent the world, negotiate their relations within it and create coherent meanings through which experience can be shared.
The semiotic is therefore not an alternative to the social. It is a further organisation of the social. Meaning develops within social relations, while giving those relations new possibilities of articulation and transformation.
This also helps clarify the relationship between Edelman's biological value and Halliday's social value. Edelman's account concerns the value-sensitive organisation of living systems: the conditions and consequences that matter to their maintenance. Halliday's social value concerns a further organisation in which what matters is implicated in the maintenance of social systems. Meaning introduces another dimension, in which significance is construed symbolically.
We should not collapse these distinctions. Biological value, social value and semiotic meaning are related, but they are not interchangeable. The emergence of meaning does not abolish mattering; it develops within a world already organised through consequential relations.
We can now state the distinction more precisely. Mattering concerns the significance of relations through their consequences for the systems involved. Meaning concerns significance organised through semiotic relations. The two may coincide in particular events, but neither can be reduced to the other.
A traffic light offers a simple illustration. Its red signal means stop within a socially established semiotic system. But the signal also matters: it changes the activities of drivers and pedestrians, helping to organise their movements and avoid collisions. Its meaning depends upon a social system of conventions, while its consequences participate in the maintenance of that system and the wider social arrangements of which it is part.
The relationship is reciprocal. Social conditions make semiotic systems possible, but semiotic systems also contribute to the organisation of social conditions. Meaning does not stand outside mattering, interpreting a world that remains untouched by its interpretations. It becomes one of the ways in which social relations are organised and transformed.
We have therefore reached a further stage in our enquiry. Mattering becomes social through the organisation of relations among living systems. Meaning emerges when those social relations acquire semiotic organisation.
But the relationship does not end there. Once meaning becomes part of social organisation, it can alter what participants value, how they understand their relationships and what they seek to maintain or change.
The final question is no longer simply how meaning emerges within mattering.
It is how meaning changes what matters.
No comments:
Post a Comment