Consider again:
We have seen that these are not merely successive arrangements of symbols. Each is a proposition: something that can be stated as the case.
But a proposition can also be challenged.
We can ask:
These questions do something different from asking what the symbols mean. They concern the status of the proposition.
Suppose someone writes:
The second clause is perfectly intelligible. Its symbols are correctly formed. But the transformation is not valid. The proposition cannot simply be accepted because it has been successfully formed.
Mathematical meaning therefore involves more than construing a relation. A proposition occupies a position with respect to other propositions. It may follow from them, contradict them, support them, or require further justification.
Proof makes this especially visible. A proof does not merely accumulate statements. It establishes relations between them so that one proposition can be taken to support another.
And this is where the interpersonal dimension becomes difficult to ignore.
The proposition is not merely there. It has a status: it can be asserted, questioned, accepted, rejected, demonstrated or refuted. Someone may challenge a proof, and the proof must provide what is required for the proposition to stand.
None of this requires an ordinary conversation. There need not be two people taking turns. A mathematical argument can remain a single continuous sequence of clauses.
But the propositions within that sequence are nevertheless not equal in status. Each is answerable to what has already been established and open to what might be established next.
Mathematics has begun to reveal something that was easy to overlook.
Its interpersonal meaning is not necessarily a matter of people talking to one another.
It may begin when a proposition becomes something that can be challenged.
No comments:
Post a Comment