The Senior Common Room was quiet.
Professor Quillibrace was reading.
Miss Stray was looking out of the window.
Mr Blottisham was standing beside the fireplace.
He looked deeply troubled.
“I don't like this one.”
Quillibrace looked up.
“Why?”
“Nothing is where it belongs.”
Miss Stray smiled.
“Isn't it?”
“The rain is under the umbrella.”
“Yes.”
“The dog is walking the man.”
“Yes.”
“The chair is carrying the parcel.”
“Yes.”
“The bread is remembering being bread.”
“An unfortunate sentence,” said Quillibrace.
“And the statue isn't sitting on the bench.”
“No.”
“The bench is sitting on the statue.”
“No.”
Blottisham stopped.
“Actually, I'm not sure what that means.”
“Good.”
“I don't like it.”
Blottisham paced.
“The town is confused.”
“Possibly.”
“Everything has been put in the wrong relation.”
Miss Stray turned.
“Wrong according to what?”
“According to what things are for.”
“That was the previous town.”
Blottisham stopped.
“Yes.”
“And what is wrong here?”
Blottisham thought.
“The things aren't beside the right things.”
“Which things should be beside which?”
“The right ones.”
Miss Stray smiled.
“You've noticed the problem.”
“What problem?”
“You've defined rightness by the relation you're trying to explain.”
Blottisham frowned.
“That sounds like something Quillibrace would say.”
“It is.”
Quillibrace returned to his book.
“I hadn't said anything.”
“You were about to.”
“I was not.”
“You were thinking it.”
“I usually do.”
Blottisham sat down.
“So what is the story about?”
Quillibrace closed his book.
“I think it is about relations.”
“Relations between what?”
“Things.”
“Obviously.”
“Not so obvious.”
Miss Stray said, “The story repeatedly separates an object from what we ordinarily expect it to be related to.”
“The postman waters letters.”
“Yes.”
“The porter polishes bread.”
“Yes.”
“The chair carries the parcel.”
“Yes.”
“The dog walks the man.”
“Yes.”
“And none of these is physically impossible.”
“Exactly.”
Blottisham looked puzzled.
“So the problem isn't possibility.”
“No.”
“It is appropriateness.”
“Closer.”
“What makes something appropriate?”
Quillibrace said, “Usually its relation to the situation.”
Blottisham thought.
“So a shoe isn't intrinsically for walking.”
“Not entirely.”
“A book isn't intrinsically for reading.”
“No.”
“A cup isn't intrinsically for drinking.”
“Not entirely.”
Blottisham looked alarmed.
“Then what is an object?”
Quillibrace smiled.
“Careful.”
Miss Stray picked up a book from the table.
“If I use this to prop open the door, is it still a book?”
“Yes,” said Blottisham.
“If I read it?”
“Yes.”
“If I stand on it?”
“Yes.”
“If I use it to swat a fly?”
“Yes.”
“If I throw it at someone?”
“Possibly.”
“If I use it to wrap a parcel?”
“Yes.”
Miss Stray put the book down.
“So the object remains relatively stable while its relations change.”
Blottisham nodded.
“Yes.”
“But the relations change what the object is doing.”
“Yes.”
“And therefore what it can mean in the situation.”
Blottisham looked thoughtful.
“So meaning isn't sitting inside the object.”
Quillibrace nodded.
“That would be one way of putting it.”
Blottisham smiled.
“That's useful.”
“Yes.”
“But inconvenient.”
“Usually.”
There was a knock.
The door opened.
A man entered carrying an umbrella.
It was raining inside the room.
He opened the umbrella.
The rain stopped.
Blottisham pointed.
“That's exactly what the story does.”
The man looked at him.
“Does what?”
“Put things in strange relations.”
The man looked at the umbrella.
Then at the ceiling.
“It's an umbrella.”
“Yes.”
“And it's raining.”
“Yes.”
“So I opened it.”
Blottisham looked at Quillibrace.
“This is perfectly normal.”
“Apparently.”
The man walked to the fireplace and held the umbrella over it.
The fire went out.
“Why did you do that?” asked Miss Stray.
The man looked surprised.
“I thought it was raining.”
“But the rain stopped.”
He looked at the umbrella.
“Oh.”
He closed it.
The fire came back.
The man left.
Blottisham stared after him.
“I don't know whether that proves anything.”
Quillibrace said, “It proves that context matters.”
Blottisham suddenly brightened.
“I know what the town has done.”
“What?”
“It has taken relations that are normally distributed across different contexts and recombined them.”
Miss Stray smiled.
“Yes.”
“So the nonsense isn't that the objects are impossible.”
“No.”
“It's that the familiar relation is displaced.”
“Yes.”
“The chair still carries.”
“Yes.”
“The bread is still bread.”
“Yes.”
“The shoe is still a shoe.”
“Yes.”
“But the relations among them have changed.”
“Exactly.”
Blottisham leaned back.
“That is rather clever.”
“It is.”
“Therefore the town is an idiot.”
Miss Stray laughed.
Quillibrace shook his head.
“You lasted remarkably long.”
Blottisham stood again.
“But why is it funny?”
Miss Stray looked at him.
“Because we recognise the ordinary relation while witnessing the displaced one.”
“Explain.”
“A dog walking a man is funny because we know what a dog ordinarily does in relation to a person.”
“Yes.”
“And what a person ordinarily does in relation to a dog.”
“Yes.”
“So the absurdity depends upon our ordinary expectations.”
“Exactly.”
“Then nonsense isn't meaningless.”
Quillibrace smiled.
“Now you're getting somewhere.”
“It depends on meaning.”
“Yes.”
“Perhaps it even reveals meaning.”
“Sometimes.”
“How?”
“By disrupting the relations through which meaning normally operates.”
Blottisham looked at the fireplace.
“So if the dog walks the man, I notice the ordinary relation between dog and man because it has been reversed.”
“Yes.”
“And if the postman waters letters, I notice what letters normally have to do with postmen.”
“Yes.”
“And if the baker bakes dough, I notice the ordinary relation between baking and bread.”
“Yes.”
Blottisham paused.
“Then nonsense can make ordinary meaning visible by making it behave strangely.”
Miss Stray nodded.
“Precisely.”
Blottisham smiled.
“I have another.”
Quillibrace looked resigned.
“Of course.”
“Suppose the ordinary relation itself is something we have learned.”
“It is.”
“Then nonsense depends on history.”
“Yes.”
“Because we have to have encountered the conventional relation before we can experience its displacement as absurd.”
“Yes.”
Blottisham pointed triumphantly.
“So the child who has never seen a dog won't find the dog walking the man strange.”
“Not in the same way.”
“And the person who has never seen a shoe won't understand why a shoe being read is funny.”
“Probably not.”
“So nonsense depends on a background of intelligibility.”
Quillibrace nodded.
“Very much.”
Blottisham sat down.
“That makes nonsense rather serious.”
“Don't tell it.”
Miss Stray looked out the window.
“There is another possibility.”
“What?”
“Perhaps nonsense doesn't merely disrupt relations.”
“What does it do instead?”
“It creates new ones.”
Blottisham looked at her.
“The Dalek.”
Quillibrace smiled.
“Of course.”
“The Dalek exterminates weeds.”
“Yes.”
“So an action normally associated with extermination enters a gardening relation.”
“Yes.”
“And then we can understand the action as gardening.”
“Exactly.”
Blottisham looked delighted.
“So the relation creates a new meaning.”
“Or makes a previously unnoticed possibility available.”
He considered this.
“That's different.”
“Yes.”
“Because the Dalek hasn't simply made a mistake.”
“No.”
“It has discovered an unusual use.”
“Yes.”
“Like the spoon.”
Miss Stray nodded.
“Like the runcible.”
“Yes.”
“Like the tree.”
“Yes.”
Blottisham looked increasingly pleased.
“We have a pattern.”
Quillibrace said, “We may.”
A silence followed.
Then Blottisham said:
“There's still something bothering me.”
“What?”
“The final sentence.”
Quillibrace looked at him.
“Which one?”
“Things don't have to belong to one another to happen together.”
“Yes.”
“That sounds obvious.”
“Does it?”
“Well, yes.”
“Then why is it useful?”
Blottisham thought.
“Because perhaps we normally assume that things happening together belong together.”
Miss Stray nodded.
“Correlation becomes relation.”
“Or relation becomes cause.”
“Yes.”
“Or proximity becomes significance.”
“Yes.”
Blottisham looked thoughtful.
“So the story is also warning us not to confuse beside with because.”
Quillibrace smiled.
“That is a very good distinction.”
Blottisham looked pleased.
“I knew it.”
“You did not.”
“I knew it after you said it.”
“That is not the same thing.”
“It is close enough.”
Another knock.
Nobody moved.
The door opened by itself.
A small boy stood outside.
He held a stone.
“Is this yours?” he asked.
Blottisham looked at it.
“No.”
The boy put it on the floor.
“Now it is.”
Blottisham stared.
“What?”
The boy walked away.
Blottisham looked at the stone.
Then at the door.
Then at Quillibrace.
“What just happened?”
Quillibrace said, “The stone became related to us.”
“But it wasn't ours.”
“No.”
“So what changed?”
Miss Stray looked at the stone.
“Nothing about the stone.”
“What, then?”
“The relation.”
Blottisham nodded slowly.
“Because it happened beside us.”
“Yes.”
“But that's not enough.”
“No.”
“Unless we take it up.”
“Yes.”
Blottisham picked up the stone.
He put it on the table.
Nobody spoke.
He looked at it.
Then at the others.
“I don't know what this means.”
Quillibrace smiled.
“You don't have to.”
Blottisham nodded.
After a moment he said:
“But I think we should leave it there.”
Miss Stray smiled.
“Why?”
Blottisham looked at the stone.
“It seems right.”
From somewhere outside came the sound of a train.
The station clock struck breakfast.
Nobody corrected it.
No comments:
Post a Comment