A difference is easy to find in nature.
One place is warmer than another. One chemical concentration is higher than another. Light is present here and absent there. A membrane separates one environment from another.
But most differences in the universe do not matter to anything.
A difference begins to matter when it has consequences for the continued organisation of some system.
This is what makes life interesting.
A living organism is not simply located in an environment. It continually exchanges matter and energy with that environment while maintaining a form of organisation of its own. Food can sustain it. Toxins can damage it. Water can preserve it. Dehydration can threaten it. A temperature change can help or harm it.
The difference is not in the temperature, the water or the chemical itself.
The difference lies in the relation between that difference and the organisation of the organism.
The same molecule can be nourishment for one organism and poison for another. The same temperature can be harmless to one species and fatal to another. What matters is therefore not simply a property of the environment.
Mattering is relational.
This gives us a useful distinction.
A difference occurs.
A difference can affect a system.
And a difference can matter to a system because of the way that system is organised.
The first two are commonplace throughout physics. The third belongs especially to life.
This does not mean that an organism has to recognise the difference. A bacterium does not need a concept of food before nutrients can sustain it. A root does not need an idea of water before water can affect its growth.
Mattering comes before meaning.
And perhaps it comes before anything we would ordinarily call experience.
This is important because it gives us a way of thinking about significance without immediately turning significance into something mental. The organism does not first construct an internal representation of the world and then decide what matters. Its very organisation already establishes differences that are consequential for it.
Life therefore introduces something new into the history of nature.
Not a new substance.
Not an invisible observer.
A new kind of relation.
The environment becomes differentiated according to what it can do to, and for, the organism.
Some possibilities sustain the organism. Others damage it. Some can be exploited. Others must be avoided. Still others make no significant difference.
The organism, in this minimal sense, has a stake in what happens.
We might call this the beginning of significance.
It is not yet meaning. There are no symbols, no concepts and no shared system of signs.
But neither is it mere physics.
Something has begun to matter.
And once something matters to an organised living system, the environment is no longer simply where the organism happens to be.
It has begun to become a world for the organism.
The next question is therefore unavoidable.
What happens when an organism is not merely affected by the differences that matter, but becomes organised around responding to them?
That is where a centre begins to emerge.
No comments:
Post a Comment