The Senior Common Room was in uproar.
Professor Quillibrace was attempting to read.
Miss Elowen Stray was attempting to drink her tea.
Mr Blottisham was attempting to explain logic.
“It's quite simple,” said Blottisham.
Quillibrace did not look up.
“That is never a promising beginning.”
“The entire town is wrong.”
Miss Stray smiled.
“Is it?”
“Obviously.”
“Why?”
“Because every argument is right.”
Quillibrace turned a page.
“That is not an argument.”
“Exactly.”
“So you're already making progress.”
Blottisham took the book from the table.
“The central problem is that the townspeople use fallacies.”
“Yes,” said Quillibrace.
“Straw man.”
“Yes.”
“Red herring.”
“Yes.”
“False dilemma.”
“Yes.”
“Appeal to ignorance.”
“Yes.”
“Circular reasoning.”
“Yes.”
“Slippery slope.”
“Yes.”
“Special pleading.”
“Yes.”
“Therefore they're all idiots.”
Quillibrace looked up.
“No.”
“Why not?”
“Because recognising a fallacy does not establish that the person making it is an idiot.”
Blottisham frowned.
“Then what does it establish?”
“That their argument fails for a particular reason.”
“Which makes them wrong.”
“About that argument.”
“Exactly.”
“So not necessarily idiots.”
Blottisham thought about this.
“I'm not convinced.”
“Why?”
“Because it would make the story less satisfying.”
Miss Stray laughed.
“The story isn't really about people making mistakes,” said Miss Stray.
“What else would it be about?” asked Blottisham.
“The way mistakes in reasoning can become persuasive when the conversational conditions allow them.”
Blottisham waved his hand.
“That's just rhetoric.”
“Yes.”
“And rhetoric isn't logic.”
“Correct.”
“Therefore rhetoric is irrelevant.”
Quillibrace put down his book.
“Congratulations.”
“What?”
“You have just committed a non sequitur.”
Blottisham beamed.
“I have?”
“Yes.”
“Excellent.”
“You're pleased?”
“I'm getting into the spirit of the story.”
Miss Stray opened the book.
“I think the Straw Man is especially interesting.”
“It's the easiest,” said Blottisham.
“How so?”
“You simply replace someone's argument with a weaker one.”
“Why does that work?”
“Because then you can defeat it.”
Quillibrace said, “More importantly, you can make the weaker argument appear to belong to your opponent.”
“Exactly.”
“Which is what the little man does to Clara.”
“Yes.”
“He repeatedly tells her what she believes.”
“Even when she hasn't said it.”
“And then argues against what he has attributed to her.”
Blottisham nodded.
“Very efficient.”
“Efficient?”
“Yes. It saves an enormous amount of time.”
Quillibrace stared at him.
“By avoiding the argument actually being made.”
“Precisely.”
Miss Stray smiled.
“Blottisham, I think you've understood the fallacy perfectly.”
“I knew I would.”
“The Red Herring,” said Quillibrace, “is different.”
“The fish,” said Blottisham.
“The fish.”
“I thought that was subtle.”
“It wasn't.”
“I liked it.”
“So did I,” said Miss Stray.
Blottisham pointed at her.
“Thank you.”
Quillibrace sighed.
“The point is that the fish continually redirects Clara from the question she is trying to answer.”
“To another question.”
“Yes.”
“Why?”
“Because the new question is easier to manipulate.”
Blottisham looked thoughtful.
“So if someone asks me a difficult question, I should answer a different one.”
“No.”
“But that seems to be what everyone does.”
“Yes.”
“Then it must be effective.”
“It can be.”
“Therefore—”
“No.”
Blottisham smiled.
“You anticipated me.”
Miss Stray turned to the bridge scene.
“I think the slippery slope is more interesting.”
“It's obviously absurd,” said Blottisham.
“Yes.”
“Someone crosses one unsafe bridge and suddenly everyone is crossing unsafe bridges.”
“Exactly.”
“That doesn't follow.”
“No.”
“Therefore it's a fallacy.”
“Usually.”
“Usually?”
Quillibrace nodded.
“A slippery-slope argument isn't fallacious merely because it predicts consequences. The problem is when the chain of consequences isn't adequately supported.”
Blottisham looked disappointed.
“So sometimes the slope really is slippery.”
“Indeed.”
“That makes things inconvenient.”
“Logic often does.”
Miss Stray said, “Perhaps that's why the town needs fallacies. They make the world simpler.”
Blottisham nodded.
“Now that is a good argument.”
Quillibrace said:
“Possibly.”
Blottisham stood.
“I have identified the deepest fallacy in the story.”
Quillibrace looked wary.
“Have you?”
“Yes.”
“What is it?”
“The fallacy of believing that identifying a fallacy refutes the conclusion.”
Miss Stray looked at him.
Quillibrace raised an eyebrow.
“Go on.”
“If I say, ‘That argument is a straw man,’ I haven't necessarily shown that the conclusion is false.”
“Correct.”
“I've shown only that the argument used to support it is defective.”
“Correct.”
“So the conclusion might still be true.”
“Correct.”
Blottisham looked delighted.
“I've been waiting for someone to say that.”
Quillibrace paused.
“Who?”
“Me.”
Miss Stray smiled.
“And that is exactly what makes the town interesting.”
“What does?” asked Blottisham.
“The fact that an argument can be fallacious and its conclusion nevertheless true.”
“Of course.”
Quillibrace nodded.
“A fallacy is not a magic word that makes the conclusion false.”
“So if I say something fallacious and happen to be right—”
“You are still right about the conclusion.”
“But wrong about the reasoning.”
“Yes.”
Blottisham thought about this.
“That seems terribly unfair.”
“Why?”
“Because people might think I was wrong.”
“You were wrong.”
“Not about the conclusion.”
“About the argument.”
Blottisham considered this carefully.
“So I can be right and wrong at the same time.”
Quillibrace nodded.
“Now you're beginning to understand the title.”
There was a pause.
Miss Stray looked at the final exchange between Clara and the town.
“She eventually stops arguing.”
“That is her great mistake,” said Blottisham.
“Why?”
“Because if you stop arguing, you've lost.”
Quillibrace looked at him.
“Have you?”
“Obviously.”
“Then what has Clara lost?”
Blottisham opened his mouth.
Nothing came out.
Miss Stray said:
“Perhaps she has discovered that refusing the question is sometimes more rational than accepting its terms.”
Quillibrace nodded.
“Precisely.”
“But isn't refusing to answer a form of evasion?”
“Sometimes.”
“So the town could accuse her of committing a fallacy.”
“It could.”
“And she couldn't refute the accusation.”
“Not necessarily.”
“Why?”
“Because the accusation itself might depend upon the very framework she is refusing.”
Blottisham stared at him.
“That is very clever.”
“I know.”
Blottisham walked to the window.
“I still think the town is cheating.”
“How?”
“It has all the arguments.”
“And Clara doesn't?”
“She has one.”
“Which one?”
“That she doesn't have to answer.”
Quillibrace said:
“That's not an argument.”
“Exactly.”
Miss Stray smiled.
“And that may be why it works.”
Blottisham turned.
“But surely every claim requires justification.”
“No,” said Quillibrace.
“Why not?”
“Because not every utterance is a claim.”
“So when Clara says ‘I don't know’?”
“She is not making a claim about the world in the same sense.”
“And when she says ‘I don't have to answer’?”
“She is refusing a conversational demand.”
Blottisham looked delighted.
“So she changes the speech act.”
Quillibrace paused.
“Yes.”
Miss Stray smiled.
“You've finally said something useful.”
“I say useful things constantly.”
“No,” said Quillibrace.
“You say many things constantly.”
Blottisham returned to the book.
“I have another problem.”
“Of course.”
“The title says every argument is right.”
“Yes.”
“But that can't be true.”
“Correct.”
“So the title is false.”
“Possibly.”
“Then why is it called that?”
Miss Stray said:
“Because the title itself behaves like one of the town's arguments.”
Blottisham stared at her.
Quillibrace nodded.
“It asserts something universal.”
“And the story immediately invites us to look for exceptions.”
“Yes.”
“So the title is part of the joke.”
“More than that.”
Quillibrace tapped the book.
“It makes us ask what right means.”
Blottisham frowned.
“Correct.”
“Persuasive.”
“Accepted.”
“Valid.”
“Justified.”
“True.”
“Effective.”
“Successful.”
Blottisham began counting on his fingers.
“They're all different.”
“Yes.”
“So the town doesn't merely have bad arguments.”
“No.”
“It has confused different standards for evaluating arguments.”
Quillibrace smiled.
“Exactly.”
Miss Stray looked at the title.
“And once those standards become interchangeable, almost anything can count as being right.”
Blottisham was silent for an unusually long time.
Then he said:
“I think I understand the town.”
Quillibrace looked up.
“Oh?”
“Yes.”
“The town isn't where people make bad arguments.”
“No?”
“It is where people stop distinguishing between an argument that works and an argument that is sound.”
Quillibrace nodded.
“Yes.”
“And between being persuasive and being true.”
“Yes.”
“And between winning an argument and answering a question.”
“Yes.”
Blottisham looked pleased.
“So the town is a university.”
Quillibrace stared at him.
Miss Stray laughed.
“Perhaps a rather specialised one.”
The room fell quiet.
Then Blottisham looked at the final line of the story.
That was an argument.
He frowned.
“She shouldn't have thought that.”
“Why?”
“Because then she's committing the very mistake she's just escaped.”
Quillibrace nodded.
“Possibly.”
“She's interpreting her own thought as an argument.”
“Yes.”
“And therefore she has fallen back into the town's logic.”
Miss Stray looked at the page.
“Or perhaps she has learned something else.”
“What?”
“That even recognising a fallacy does not put you outside the world of argument.”
Blottisham considered this.
“So we're trapped.”
“No.”
“How do we get out?”
“We don't.”
“Why not?”
“Because reasoning isn't the prison.”
Quillibrace closed the book.
“It's one of the things we use to find out whether the door is a door.”
Blottisham nodded slowly.
“And if it isn't?”
“Then,” said Miss Stray, “we ask a better question.”
There was a pause.
Blottisham looked towards the door.
“Is that the exit?”
Quillibrace said nothing.
Miss Stray said nothing.
Blottisham opened the door.
Behind it was the Senior Common Room.
He closed it.
He opened it again.
The same room.
He looked back at the others.
“I think we've been here before.”
Quillibrace sighed.
“That is not a fallacy.”
“What is it?”
“An observation.”
Blottisham looked pleased.
“Excellent.”
He stepped through the door.
Then came back.
“I've just realised something.”
“What?”
“The door is a red herring.”
Quillibrace frowned.
“Why?”
“Because I thought it was the exit.”
Miss Stray smiled.
“And is it?”
Blottisham looked at the door.
He looked at Quillibrace.
He looked at Miss Stray.
Then he said:
“I don't know.”
For once, nobody corrected him.