Wednesday, 7 October 2026

The Senior Common Room Discusses The Man Who Had Too Many Futures

Professor Quillibrace finished reading the manuscript.

Mr Blottisham was already shaking his head.

“I don't believe it.”

Miss Elowen Stray looked up.

“Which part?”

“The man.”

“Daniel?”

“Yes.”

“What don't you believe?”

“That he can be in all those places.”

“He isn't.”

Blottisham frowned.

“There are photographs.”

“Yes.”

“Photographs don't lie.”

Quillibrace looked at him.

“They can.”

“No. They show what happened.”

“Usually.”

Blottisham leaned forward.

“But if Daniel is in four photographs doing four different things—”

“He did four different things.”

“Exactly.”

“So?”

“So he must have done them all.”

Miss Stray smiled.

“Not necessarily.”

Blottisham looked at her.

“You're going to say they were possibilities.”

“Yes.”

“But possibilities aren't real.”

“Are they not?”

Blottisham sat back.

“Well, they aren't things.”

“Neither is tomorrow.”

“Tomorrow is real.”

“Is it?”

“Of course.”

“Then why can't you show me tomorrow?”

Blottisham thought about this.

“Because it hasn't happened.”

“Exactly.”

Quillibrace folded his hands.

“The story is playing with a distinction we often blur: what can happen and what does happen.”

Blottisham nodded.

“Possibility and actuality.”

“Yes.”

“So Daniel has lots of possibilities but only one actuality.”

“At any particular point, yes.”

Blottisham looked pleased.

“That's easy.”

Quillibrace waited.

“Too easy?”

“Almost certainly.”

Blottisham stood up.

“I've got it. Daniel is a wave.”

Miss Stray raised an eyebrow.

“Why?”

“Because he has lots of possibilities.”

“And when he chooses one?”

“Then he becomes a particle.”

Quillibrace sighed.

“You have managed to turn an interesting story into a man made of soup.”

“I have not.”

“You have.”

“A wave becomes a particle.”

“No.”

Blottisham looked offended.

“That's what everyone says.”

“Not quite.”

Quillibrace reached for a pencil.

“The wave–particle problem in physics is not simply that an object is sometimes one thing and sometimes another. Nor is a quantum wave merely a cloud of things the object might personally decide to do.”

“So Daniel isn't choosing his future?”

“He is a fictional character.”

“That's not an answer.”

“It is the safest one.”

Miss Stray smiled.

“The story is not really asking us to decide what Daniel is.”

Blottisham sat down again.

“Then what is it asking?”

“What happens when we describe him in relation to what might happen, and then in relation to what actually happens?”

Blottisham looked at the manuscript.

“The photographs.”

“Yes.”

“They show different possibilities.”

“Some do.”

“And the one that actually happened.”

“Yes.”

“So the photograph doesn't show Daniel.”

“It shows Daniel in a particular event.”

Blottisham nodded slowly.

“The relation matters.”

“Very much.”

Quillibrace looked pleased.

“Now you're getting somewhere.”

Blottisham frowned.

“I don't like the phrase ‘getting somewhere.’”

“Why?”

“Because if there are four roads, you might get somewhere four times.”

Miss Stray laughed.

Quillibrace ignored him.

“The important point is that possibility isn't necessarily an alternative object. It can be a range of possible relations or events.”

“So Daniel's possibilities aren't other Daniels.”

“Exactly.”

“But the story gives them rooms.”

“Because stories need somewhere to put things.”

Blottisham looked towards the door.

“That room was rather disturbing.”

“Why?”

“Because everything that could happen seemed to be waiting.”

Miss Stray nodded.

“Yes.”

“And some things stopped being possible when Clara looked at them.”

“Yes.”

“Is that quantum mechanics?”

“No.”

“Are you sure?”

“Quite.”

“Then why did it do that?”

“Because the story wanted to make possibility feel fragile.”

Blottisham considered this.

“Possibility can disappear.”

“Of course.”

“When?”

“When the conditions that made it possible cease to obtain.”

“So possibility has a history.”

Miss Stray smiled.

“Yes.”

Quillibrace looked up.

“And that is one of the more interesting things the story gives us.”

Blottisham leaned forward.

“How?”

“Before Daniel takes a road, several futures are open to him. After he takes one, the relation has changed. The other roads haven't become meaningless. They have become roads he did not take.”

“So his past contains unrealised futures.”

“Yes.”

“And his future contains unrealised possibilities.”

“Yes.”

Blottisham was silent.

Then he said:

“So everyone is surrounded by ghosts.”

Miss Stray tilted her head.

“Perhaps.”

“Things they might have done.”

“Yes.”

“People they might have become.”

“Yes.”

“Places they might have gone.”

“Yes.”

Blottisham looked suddenly uncomfortable.

“That sounds exhausting.”

Quillibrace nodded.

“Possibility usually is.”

There was a pause.

Blottisham looked again at the final photograph.

“There's something else.”

“What?” asked Miss Stray.

“The photograph of Clara.”

“The one saying The Person Who Could Have Gone Anywhere?”

“Yes.”

“She hasn't gone anywhere yet.”

“Exactly.”

“So the photograph shows a future possibility.”

“Apparently.”

“But it also says she did go somewhere.”

“Apparently.”

Blottisham looked suspicious.

“So photographs in Bellwether don't merely record the past.”

“No.”

“They can record the future.”

“Apparently.”

“Then they're not photographs.”

Quillibrace raised an eyebrow.

“What are they?”

Blottisham thought.

“Prophecies with better lighting.”

Miss Stray laughed.

Quillibrace almost smiled.

“Not entirely useless.”

Blottisham sat back.

“So perhaps the strange thing isn't that Daniel has too many futures.”

“What is it?”

“That we normally pretend he has only one.”

Miss Stray looked at him.

“That is much closer.”

Quillibrace nodded.

“An actual event does not necessarily tell us that the alternatives were unreal in every sense. It tells us that they were not actualised.”

Blottisham pointed at him.

“There. That's the word.”

“Yes.”

“Actualised.”

“Yes.”

“Then Daniel is a collection of things that could be actualised.”

“Careful.”

“Why?”

“You're about to turn a person into a list.”

Blottisham paused.

“Fair point.”

Miss Stray looked thoughtful.

“Perhaps the story is also saying something about identity.”

“Here we go,” said Blottisham.

“Daniel remains Daniel through all those possibilities.”

“Even the things he doesn't do?”

“Yes.”

“So what he could do belongs to him, even when he doesn't do it.”

“Perhaps.”

“And what he actually does doesn't exhaust what he could do.”

“Yes.”

Blottisham frowned.

“That sounds like two Daniels.”

“No.”

“One actual Daniel and one possible Daniel.”

“No.”

“Then what?”

Miss Stray looked at him.

“One Daniel, encountered in different relations.”

Blottisham was silent.

Then:

“That sounds suspiciously like the category-error story.”

Quillibrace nodded.

“Good.”

“Why good?”

“Because you're beginning to notice that the stories are not as separate as you thought.”

Blottisham looked worried.

“I preferred them when they were just towns.”

Miss Stray smiled.

“They were never just towns.”

The three sat quietly for a while.

Then Blottisham picked up the manuscript.

“There's one thing I still don't understand.”

Quillibrace sighed.

“What?”

“If Daniel has all these possibilities, and one of them becomes actual, where do the others go?”

Miss Stray answered before Quillibrace could.

“Nowhere.”

Blottisham looked at her.

“But they aren't actual.”

“No.”

“So where are they?”

She pointed towards the manuscript.

“In the space between what could happen and what does.”

Blottisham considered this.

“That sounds like a very crowded space.”

“It probably is.”

A faint sound came from outside the Common Room.

A train whistle.

Blottisham looked towards the window.

“Is that Daniel?”

“No,” said Quillibrace.

“How do you know?”

“Because Daniel is fictional.”

Blottisham nodded.

“Ah.”

Another whistle sounded.

He looked towards the door.

“But if he were real…”

Quillibrace closed his eyes.

“Don't.”

Blottisham stood.

“I was only going to ask which road he took.”

Miss Stray smiled.

“Perhaps all four.”

Blottisham opened the door.

Quillibrace shouted:

“Blottisham!”

Blottisham turned.

“What?”

“Which way are you going?”

He looked at the corridor.

Then at the four possible directions.

He smiled.

“I haven't decided.”

And walked through the door.

For several seconds, nobody spoke.

Then Miss Stray looked at Quillibrace.

“Which way did he go?”

Quillibrace listened.

“I don't know.”

From somewhere down the corridor came Blottisham's voice.

“Neither do I.”

A pause.

Then:

“But I think I've arrived.”

The Man Who Had Too Many Futures

Clara first saw the man at a crossroads.

There were four roads.

The man stood in the middle of them.

He looked at the signs.

NORTH

SOUTH

EAST

WEST

Clara approached him.

“Are you lost?”

“No.”

“Then where are you going?”

“I haven't decided.”

He was holding a small suitcase.

Clara looked at the four roads.

“Which one will you take?”

The man smiled.

“That depends.”

“On what?”

“On what happens.”

As if to prove the point, a little boy came running around the corner.

A red ball bounced into the road.

The man stepped forward.

A cart came around the corner.

The man grabbed the boy.

They both stumbled backwards.

The ball rolled into the gutter.

The man stood up.

“Thank you,” said Clara.

The man looked surprised.

“For what?”

“You saved the boy.”

“Yes.”

“Then you won't be going north.”

The man looked at her.

“Why not?”

“Because you have to stay here.”

“Do I?”

Clara pointed at the boy.

The boy was already running home.

The man picked up his suitcase.

Then he walked north.

Clara watched him disappear.

She stood at the crossroads for a moment.

Then she noticed something strange.

There were footprints in the mud.

Four sets.

One led north.

One led south.

One led east.

One led west.

Clara followed the northern footprints.

They led to a small café.

Inside, the man was sitting at a table.

“You're here,” Clara said.

“Yes.”

“I just saw you leave.”

“Yes.”

“You went north.”

“Yes.”

“Then how did you get here?”

“I walked.”

“From the north?”

“No.”

“From the south?”

“No.”

Clara pointed towards the door.

“You came from the crossroads.”

“Yes.”

“But you went north.”

“Yes.”

“And now you're here.”

“Yes.”

She sat down.

“Which road did you take?”

The man looked at her.

“The road I took.”

“That isn't an answer.”

“It is now.”

A waitress brought him coffee.

Clara watched him drink it.

“What is your name?”

“Daniel.”

“Daniel, have we met before?”

“Yes.”

“When?”

“Tomorrow.”

Clara stared at him.

“Tomorrow?”

“Yes.”

“But this is today.”

Daniel nodded.

“That is why it hasn't happened yet.”

He finished his coffee and left.

Clara remained at the table.

The waitress came over.

“Is he always like that?”

“Like what?”

“Certain.”

“About what?”

“Everything.”

Clara looked towards the door.

“He didn't seem certain.”

The waitress smiled.

“He never does.”

That afternoon Clara went to the library.

There was a photograph on the desk.

It showed Daniel standing at the crossroads.

In the photograph he was walking south.

Clara turned it over.

Written on the back was:

Daniel, yesterday.

She took the photograph to the librarian.

“Who took this?”

“I did.”

“When?”

“Tomorrow.”

Clara put the photograph down.

“You're making fun of me.”

“No.”

“Then why does everyone keep saying tomorrow?”

The librarian looked at her.

“Because Daniel is difficult to photograph.”

“Why?”

“Because photographs only show what happened.”

Clara looked at the photograph.

“But he is walking south.”

“Yes.”

“I saw him walk north.”

“Yes.”

“So which is correct?”

“Both.”

“That is impossible.”

The librarian smiled.

“Not necessarily.”

She opened a drawer.

Inside were more photographs.

Daniel at the crossroads.

Daniel walking north.

Daniel walking south.

Daniel walking east.

Daniel walking west.

Daniel sitting in the café.

Daniel entering the library.

Daniel standing outside the station.

Daniel boarding a train.

Daniel watching a train leave.

Daniel holding a red ball.

Daniel holding no ball.

Clara stared at them.

“Are these all real?”

“They're photographs.”

“That isn't what I asked.”

The librarian looked at her.

“They all happened.”

“How?”

“Not all at once.”

Clara picked up the photograph of Daniel walking west.

“When did this happen?”

“Yesterday.”

She picked up the photograph of Daniel walking east.

“And this?”

“Tomorrow.”

Clara put both photographs down.

“But tomorrow hasn't happened.”

“For you.”

The librarian returned the photographs to the drawer.

“For Daniel?”

She closed it.

“Perhaps.”

That evening Clara returned to the crossroads.

Daniel was there.

He was standing exactly where she had first seen him.

“You came back,” he said.

“Yes.”

“Why?”

“I want to know which road you took.”

Daniel looked at the four roads.

“I took one.”

“Which one?”

He pointed west.

Clara looked at him.

“But I saw you go north.”

“Yes.”

“And there is a photograph of you going south.”

“Yes.”

“And another of you going east.”

“Yes.”

“And now you're telling me you went west.”

“Yes.”

“How many times did you leave?”

Daniel thought about this.

“Once.”

Clara laughed.

“That makes no sense.”

“It makes sense to me.”

“You can't take four roads at once.”

“I didn't.”

“Then what happened?”

Daniel looked at the crossroads.

“For a while, I could have taken any of them.”

“And then?”

“Then I took one.”

Clara looked at the roads.

“So the others didn't happen.”

Daniel shook his head.

“No.”

“They could have happened.”

“Yes.”

“But they didn't.”

“No.”

She pointed towards the western road.

“And this one did.”

“Yes.”

She looked at him.

“Then why are the others in the photographs?”

Daniel was silent.

A wind moved through the trees.

“They belong to what I could have done.”

Clara frowned.

“But they aren't real.”

Daniel smiled.

“That depends on what you mean by real.”

The next morning Clara woke early.

On the table beside her bed was a letter.

It was addressed to her.

She opened it.

Inside was a single sentence:

I could have written this.

There was no signature.

She went back to the crossroads.

Daniel was waiting.

“You wrote me a letter.”

“No.”

“I have it.”

“Then someone wrote it.”

“It says you could have written it.”

“Yes.”

“Did you?”

“No.”

“Did you intend to?”

“I might have.”

“But you didn't.”

“No.”

Clara looked at him.

“Then why does it exist?”

Daniel shrugged.

“Because someone wrote it.”

“Someone who might have been you.”

“Yes.”

She sat on the low stone wall.

“Are you one person?”

“Yes.”

“How many things have you done?”

Daniel thought.

“Quite a few.”

“How many things could you have done?”

He looked at the four roads.

“More.”

“How many?”

He smiled.

“Too many.”

That afternoon Clara followed Daniel.

He walked through the town.

Sometimes he stopped.

Sometimes he turned.

Sometimes he crossed the street just before a carriage passed.

Sometimes he did not.

Once he reached for a door and stopped.

“Why didn't you open it?” Clara asked.

“Because I did.”

“But you didn't.”

“Not this time.”

They came to an old building at the edge of town.

Daniel unlocked the door.

Inside was a long room.

There were hundreds of objects.

A chair.

A cup.

A violin.

A red scarf.

A letter.

A train ticket.

A broken watch.

A photograph.

A key.

On the far wall were dozens of doors.

Each had a small brass plate.

THE ROAD HE TOOK

THE ROAD HE DIDN'T TAKE

THE WORDS HE SAID

THE WORDS HE DIDN'T SAY

THE DOOR HE OPENED

THE DOOR HE LEFT CLOSED

Clara turned to Daniel.

“What is this place?”

He looked around.

“My possibilities.”

She walked to the nearest door.

“What's behind it?”

“Something that could have happened.”

She opened it.

There was a railway platform.

Daniel was standing beside a train.

She closed the door.

She opened another.

Daniel was sitting beside a woman in a garden.

Another.

Daniel was walking alone through rain.

Another.

Daniel was much older.

Another.

He was carrying a child.

Another.

He was standing at the crossroads.

Again.

And again.

And again.

Clara stepped back.

“There are too many.”

“Yes.”

“Do they all happen?”

“No.”

“Then why are they here?”

Daniel looked at her.

“They were possible.”

Clara looked at the doors.

“Are they still possible?”

“Some.”

“Which ones?”

“I don't know.”

She pointed to one.

“This one?”

“Perhaps.”

“And this?”

“Perhaps.”

“And that one?”

Daniel smiled.

“Not anymore.”

“Why?”

“Because you're looking at it.”

Clara turned sharply.

The door she had been pointing at was gone.

Only a blank wall remained.

“What happened?”

“It happened.”

“But what?”

Daniel looked at the empty space.

“You asked.”

She looked at him.

“And that changed it?”

“No.”

“Then what did?”

Daniel was quiet.

“Something happened.”

They walked deeper into the room.

At the very end was a small door.

There was no brass plate.

Clara opened it.

On the other side was the crossroads.

Four roads.

Four signs.

Daniel standing in the middle.

But this Daniel was looking directly at her.

He smiled.

“Which way will you go?”

Clara stepped through.

She turned around.

Daniel was gone.

She was standing alone at the crossroads.

The four roads stretched away from her.

For a moment she could imagine herself taking any one of them.

North.

South.

East.

West.

She stood there.

Then she heard footsteps behind her.

She turned.

Daniel was walking towards her.

“You're here,” she said.

“Yes.”

“But you were just there.”

“I know.”

She looked at the four roads.

“Which one did you take?”

Daniel pointed.

“Yours.”

Clara laughed.

“That isn't one of the choices.”

“It is now.”

She looked at him.

“Daniel, are you the man in all those photographs?”

“Yes.”

“Even the ones where you did something different?”

“Yes.”

“Even the things you didn't do?”

Daniel thought for a moment.

“No.”

“Then what are they?”

He looked down the four roads.

“Things I could have done.”

“And the things you actually did?”

He looked at Clara.

“They're the things that happened.”

She nodded slowly.

“So which one is the real you?”

Daniel smiled.

“The one that happens.”

Clara looked back at the crossroads.

For a moment, she thought she could see the other roads disappearing.

Then she realised they were not disappearing.

They were simply no longer hers.

Daniel handed her the small suitcase.

“What's this?”

“You were carrying it.”

“I wasn't.”

“You will be.”

“When?”

“Soon.”

She opened it.

Inside was a photograph.

She took it out.

It showed Clara standing at the crossroads.

There were four roads behind her.

Daniel was beside her.

On the back was written:

THE PERSON WHO COULD HAVE GONE ANYWHERE.

Clara turned it over again.

In the photograph, she was smiling.

She looked at Daniel.

“Did this happen?”

“Yes.”

“When?”

“Tomorrow.”

She looked at the road ahead.

“And now?”

Daniel smiled.

“Now we have to find out.”

They walked on.

Behind them, at the crossroads, four sets of footprints remained.

For a while.

Then three.

Then two.

Then one.

And none of them knew exactly when the others had disappeared.

The Senior Common Room Discusses The Town Where Nothing Had a Beginning

Professor Quillibrace put the manuscript down.

Nobody spoke for a moment.

Mr Blottisham leaned back in his chair.

“Well,” he said, “that's ridiculous.”

Miss Elowen Stray looked at him.

“Which part?”

“All of it.”

Professor Quillibrace folded his hands.

“An admirably precise criticism.”

“The town is impossible.”

“Yes.”

“Nothing has a beginning.”

“Yes.”

“And yet everything happens.”

“Yes.”

Blottisham frowned.

“Then the story contradicts itself.”

Miss Stray shook her head.

“Not quite.”

“Why not?”

“Because the story never says that nothing happens. It says that no particular change is enough to mark the point at which something becomes different.”

Blottisham looked at her.

“That sounds like a contradiction with better manners.”

Quillibrace raised an eyebrow.

“Noted.”

Blottisham stood and began pacing.

“Take the wall. It starts white and ends blue.”

“Yes.”

“So it becomes blue.”

“Yes.”

“Then there must be a moment when it becomes blue.”

“Why?”

“Because before that moment it wasn't blue, and after it was.”

Quillibrace nodded.

“That is the interesting question.”

Blottisham stopped.

“But surely one of the brushstrokes did it.”

“Which one?”

“The last one.”

“Why the last?”

“Because after the last one the wall was blue.”

“Was it not blue after the second-last?”

“No.”

“So the second-last brushstroke did not make it blue?”

“No.”

“And the one before that?”

“No.”

“Then what makes the last one different?”

Blottisham opened his mouth.

Closed it.

Opened it again.

“It was last.”

“That is a temporal property,” said Miss Stray. “Not necessarily a causal one.”

Blottisham looked annoyed.

“Now you're making the paint philosophical.”

“The paint was already doing that.”

Quillibrace turned a page.

“The same problem appears with the old man's hair.”

“Yes,” said Blottisham. “That one is obviously nonsense. At some point he is bald.”

“When?”

“When he has no hair.”

“He doesn't need to have no hair to be bald.”

“Exactly.”

“So how much hair can he have and still be bald?”

Blottisham hesitated.

“That depends.”

“On what?”

“On the definition.”

“Good.”

Quillibrace looked almost pleased.

“So the problem isn't simply that the old man changes gradually. It is that our category—bald—appears to have a boundary, while the physical change does not supply one.”

Miss Stray leaned forward.

“The story keeps putting the same question in different forms. When does a wall become blue? When does a man become bald? When does a child become eight? When does a road become a new road?”

“And when does a train leave,” said Blottisham.

“Precisely.”

Blottisham smiled.

“I understand it.”

Quillibrace looked suspicious.

“Do you?”

“Nothing changes at any particular moment.”

Miss Stray considered this.

“That's close.”

“But everything changes.”

“Yes.”

“So—”

Blottisham pointed triumphantly.

“Therefore nothing changes.”

There was a pause.

Quillibrace looked at Miss Stray.

Miss Stray looked at Quillibrace.

Blottisham waited.

“No,” said Quillibrace.

“Why not?”

“Because you have just performed the exact move the story is warning us about.”

“What move?”

“You've treated the absence of a particular boundary as the absence of change.”

Blottisham sat down.

“That seems unfair.”

“Change is not obliged to provide you with a certificate.”

Miss Stray smiled.

“The deeper problem may be that we often assume that gradual change must eventually produce a discrete event.”

“Yes,” said Quillibrace. “And the paradox asks what happens when the world supplies the gradual change but not the event we want.”

Blottisham looked thoughtful.

“So the town has change without beginnings.”

“Perhaps.”

“And beginnings without changes?”

“No.”

“Why not?”

“Because a beginning is itself a change in status.”

Blottisham nodded.

“Right.”

He paused.

“So the town has neither.”

“No.”

“But it still has a population.”

“Yes.”

“And houses.”

“Yes.”

“And trains.”

“Yes.”

“And people.”

“Yes.”

Blottisham looked increasingly troubled.

“How did they get there?”

Miss Stray smiled.

“That is precisely what the story refuses to tell us.”

Blottisham stared at the manuscript.

“I don't like that.”

“You prefer origins.”

“I prefer explanations.”

“Those are not the same thing.”

Quillibrace glanced up.

“Indeed. An explanation may tell us how something follows from something else without identifying a single first event.”

Blottisham frowned.

“So Bellweather could have a history without having a beginning.”

“Yes.”

“That's absurd.”

“Why?”

“Because history starts somewhere.”

“Does it?”

Blottisham paused.

Miss Stray watched him carefully.

“If every event has a prior event,” she said, “we can ask for the beginning. But if the relation is extended indefinitely, the demand for a beginning may be something we have added.”

Blottisham looked at her.

“So you're saying the universe doesn't owe us a first page.”

“I'm saying the existence of a story doesn't guarantee a first sentence.”

Quillibrace nodded.

“An excellent distinction.”

Blottisham brightened.

“Then the town is a book.”

“No.”

“A story?”

“No.”

“A history?”

“No.”

“A book containing a history?”

Quillibrace sighed.

“Must everything become a container?”

“I find containers reassuring.”

Miss Stray laughed.

Quillibrace returned to the manuscript.

“There is another feature worth noticing.”

“The sign?” asked Miss Stray.

“Yes. Nothing Starts Here.”

Blottisham leaned over.

“That's obviously a warning.”

“Or a description.”

“Or a rule.”

“Or a conclusion.”

“Or a lie.”

Quillibrace nodded.

“Exactly.”

Blottisham stared at the sign.

“If the sign says nothing starts here, then the sign itself didn't start here.”

Miss Stray looked at him.

“Go on.”

“It must have been put here somewhere else.”

“Possibly.”

“So the town has moved.”

“Possibly.”

“Or the sign has.”

“Possibly.”

Blottisham smiled.

“I've solved it.”

Quillibrace looked wary.

“The town has no beginning because it was moved here from somewhere else.”

“Where?”

Blottisham thought.

“Another town.”

“What town?”

“Bellweather.”

Silence.

Miss Stray slowly turned towards him.

“Bellweather?”

“Yes.”

Quillibrace looked down at the manuscript.

Then at Blottisham.

“That is not the name of the town.”

“It could have been.”

“It isn't.”

“Perhaps that's why it changed.”

Miss Stray smiled.

“Perhaps you've discovered another paradox.”

“I have?”

“No.”

She glanced at Quillibrace.

“But we may have discovered something else.”

“What?”

“That Blottisham has just given the town a beginning.”

Blottisham looked pleased.

“Excellent.”

Quillibrace shook his head.

“No, Blottisham.”

“What?”

“You've given it an earlier town.”

Blottisham considered this.

“That's practically the same thing.”

“It isn't.”

“Why not?”

“Because now you have to explain where Bellweather began.”

Blottisham stared at him.

The room was silent.

Then Miss Stray began to laugh.

Blottisham pointed accusingly at Quillibrace.

“You knew that would happen.”

“Of course.”

“You let me do it.”

“I was curious how far you'd get.”

Blottisham sat back.

“I don't like this paradox.”

“You've only just arrived.”

He looked at her.

Miss Stray smiled.

For a moment nobody spoke.

Then, from somewhere beyond the Common Room, came the faint sound of a train.

Blottisham looked towards the door.

“Did that just start?”

Quillibrace listened.

“No.”

The sound continued.

Blottisham waited.

“So when did it begin?”

Miss Stray looked at the manuscript.

“I don't think it did.”

The train whistle sounded again.

Blottisham stood.

“I'd better check.”

Quillibrace looked up sharply.

“Don't.”

“Why?”

“Because if you go through that door, we may have to decide whether you have left.”

Blottisham stopped.

Miss Stray looked at him.

Then at the door.

Then back at him.

Blottisham slowly sat down.

“I've decided,” he said.

“What?”

“I'm not going anywhere until I've already gone.”

Quillibrace closed the manuscript.

“Progress.”

Outside, the train continued to leave.

Nobody could say when it had begun.

The Town Where Nothing Had a Beginning

Clara noticed the sign as soon as she stepped off the train.

WELCOME TO BELLWETHER

Underneath, in smaller letters, someone had added:

NOTHING STARTS HERE.

She looked back at the train.

It had already begun to leave.

Or rather, one wheel had moved.

Then another.

Then another.

The train was still mostly there.

Clara waited until it had disappeared.

“Was that the beginning?” she asked.

The porter looked at her.

“Of what?”

“The train leaving.”

He considered this.

“No.”

“But it wasn't here a moment ago.”

“Most of it was.”

He picked up her suitcase.

“Welcome to Bellwether.”

They walked towards the town.

At the first house, a man was painting a wall.

The wall was almost entirely blue.

There was one small white patch near the bottom.

“How long has he been painting that?” Clara asked.

“Three days.”

“And when did it become blue?”

The porter stopped.

“When the last white bit disappeared.”

Clara looked at the wall.

The painter dipped his brush into the tin.

He painted another stroke.

The white patch became smaller.

“Was that it?” Clara asked.

“No.”

Another stroke.

“No.”

Another.

“No.”

The painter continued.

At last there was no white visible at all.

Clara looked at the wall.

“When did it become blue?”

The porter shrugged.

“It didn't.”

“But it's blue.”

“Yes.”

“So it became blue.”

“No particular stroke made it blue.”

Clara looked at the painter.

He was now painting the same wall blue again.

“Why?”

“He doesn't like to leave things unfinished.”

They continued into town.

At the barber's, an old man sat in the chair.

The barber held a comb in one hand and a pair of scissors in the other.

“How much hair does he have?” Clara asked.

“Less than yesterday.”

“How much less?”

“Three hairs.”

The barber snipped.

“One more.”

He snipped again.

“And now?”

The porter looked at the old man's head.

“Still not bald.”

The barber snipped again.

“And now?”

“Still not bald.”

Again.

“And now?”

“Still not bald.”

Clara began to feel that she was being deliberately difficult.

“How many hairs would he have to lose before he was bald?”

The barber smiled.

“One.”

“One?”

“Yes.”

“Then surely—”

“But losing one hair cannot make a person bald.”

Clara looked at the old man.

“How many hairs does he have?”

The barber paused.

“I don't know.”

“But you just said he wasn't bald.”

“Yes.”

“So you know he has enough hair not to be bald.”

“Yes.”

“And if you remove one hair—”

“He still has enough hair not to be bald.”

“And another?”

“Yes.”

“And another?”

“Yes.”

Clara looked at the old man.

The old man looked back.

“How long have you been sitting there?”

“Since before I was bald.”

“But you aren't bald.”

“Exactly.”

The barber snipped.

The old man remained unchanged.

Or almost unchanged.

They left.

In the square, a little girl was standing beside a fountain.

She was holding a wooden box.

“What is in it?” Clara asked.

“Tomorrow,” said the girl.

Clara looked inside.

It was empty.

“How can tomorrow be in an empty box?”

“It isn't.”

“Then why say it is?”

“Because it isn't here yet.”

The girl closed the box.

“How old are you?”

“Seven.”

“When will you be eight?”

“Tomorrow.”

“And when did you become seven?”

The girl thought about this.

“I don't know.”

“Yesterday?”

“I was seven yesterday.”

“The day before?”

“Yes.”

“The day before that?”

“Yes.”

Clara crouched down.

“So when did you become seven?”

The girl looked puzzled.

“I've always been seven.”

“That can't be right.”

“It is here.”

She pointed to the square.

A large clock stood above the fountain.

Its second hand moved.

Clara watched it.

One second.

Another.

Another.

“When does one second become the next?”

The girl smiled.

“It doesn't.”

“Then how does time pass?”

The girl opened her wooden box.

“Ask tomorrow.”

She walked away.

Clara looked at the porter.

“I don't like this town.”

“You've only just arrived.”

“Exactly.”

They continued.

The road out of town was being repaired.

A group of workers were replacing stones one at a time.

“How many stones were there yesterday?” Clara asked.

“Exactly the same number.”

“And today?”

“Exactly the same number.”

“But you're replacing them.”

“Yes.”

“How can the number remain the same?”

“We remove one and put another in its place.”

“So when does it become a new road?”

The foreman looked at the road.

“It doesn't.”

“But eventually every stone will have been replaced.”

“Yes.”

“Then it will be a different road.”

“No.”

“Why not?”

“Because no particular stone made it a different road.”

Clara stared at him.

The foreman smiled politely.

“Would you like to help?”

“No.”

“That's sensible.”

They walked on.

At the centre of town stood the Town Hall.

Above the door was another sign.

NO BEGINNING

Clara pushed the door open.

Inside, a clerk sat behind a desk.

“I'd like to speak to whoever is responsible for this town.”

“You'll have to wait.”

“Until when?”

“Until they arrive.”

“When will they arrive?”

“When they have arrived.”

Clara closed her eyes.

“Can I ask you something?”

“Certainly.”

“When did Bellwether begin?”

The clerk smiled.

“It didn't.”

“Every town has a beginning.”

“Then show me ours.”

The clerk opened a drawer.

Inside was a photograph.

It showed Bellwether.

The square.

The fountain.

The clock.

The Town Hall.

The railway station.

Clara pointed to the station.

“When was this taken?”

“Long ago.”

“How long?”

“Before you arrived.”

“Who took the photograph?”

“Someone who had already arrived.”

“When did they arrive?”

“Before you.”

“When did the first person arrive?”

The clerk looked at her.

“There was no first person.”

“That is impossible.”

“Why?”

“Because someone must have arrived first.”

“Why?”

“Because otherwise nobody could have arrived.”

The clerk nodded thoughtfully.

“That sounds reasonable.”

“It is reasonable.”

“Then perhaps you can tell me who arrived first.”

Clara opened her mouth.

Nothing came out.

The clerk put the photograph away.

Outside, the clock struck twelve.

Then twelve again.

Then twelve again.

Clara stepped into the square.

The little girl was there.

The old man was there.

The painter was there.

The road workers were there.

The porter was there.

Everyone was doing something.

But nothing seemed to have started.

The painter painted.

The barber cut.

The workers replaced stones.

The clock moved.

The girl waited for tomorrow.

The train arrived.

A wheel turned.

Then another.

Then another.

Clara watched.

“Now,” she said.

Everyone stopped.

“What?”

“The train.”

The porter looked at her.

“It has begun to leave.”

“No,” said Clara. “This time I saw it.”

One wheel turned.

“That's not enough.”

Another.

“Still not enough.”

Another.

“Still not enough.”

The train moved farther away.

Clara ran after it.

“Wait!”

The porter called after her.

“Don't worry!”

She stopped.

“Why?”

“You haven't missed it.”

“But it's leaving.”

“Yes.”

“When does it leave?”

The porter thought about this.

“When it's gone.”

Clara watched the train disappear.

Then she looked back at Bellwether.

The sign above the station had changed.

WELCOME TO BELLWETHER

Underneath, in smaller letters:

YOU ARE ALREADY HERE.

Clara walked towards the town.

After a while she noticed something.

The town was smaller than it had been.

Not much smaller.

Just one house.

Then another.

A shop disappeared.

A bench vanished.

The fountain became smaller.

The clock lost a hand.

“What's happening?” Clara asked.

The porter looked around.

“Nothing.”

“But the town is disappearing.”

“No.”

Clara pointed.

“There was a house there.”

“Yes.”

“And now there isn't.”

“Yes.”

“So something happened.”

“No particular house disappearing changed the town.”

One more house disappeared.

Then another.

Clara looked at the porter.

“Stop.”

“What?”

“Whatever you're doing.”

“We aren't doing anything.”

The town continued to disappear.

The square became smaller.

The Town Hall vanished.

The railway station became a single door.

The door became a window.

The window became a patch of light.

The patch of light became—

Clara blinked.

She was standing outside the station.

The train was still there.

The porter was still holding her suitcase.

The sign still read:

WELCOME TO BELLWETHER

Underneath:

NOTHING STARTS HERE.

Clara stared at it.

“How long have I been here?”

The porter smiled.

“You've only just arrived.”

Clara looked at the train.

One wheel turned.

Then another.

She waited.

“Is this the beginning?”

The porter looked at the train.

“No.”

“Then when did it begin?”

He smiled.

“That,” he said, “is why we don't have beginnings.”

The train moved.

Clara watched it leave.

She could not say exactly when it had started.

And for some reason, that seemed to be the only thing in Bellwether that had happened.

She walked into town.

Behind her, the sign changed.

WELCOME TO BELLWETHER

Then:

WELCOME

Then:

COME IN

Then, very slowly:

BEGIN

The Senior Common Room Discusses The Town Where Everything Was Something Else

Professor Quillibrace put the book down.

Mr Blottisham was frowning.

Miss Stray was smiling.

“Well,” said Blottisham, “I don't see the problem.”

Quillibrace looked at him.

“The station isn't a station.”

“It is.”

“The map isn't the town.”

“It isn't.”

“The word Clara isn't Clara.”

“Correct.”

“The sign isn't the town.”

“Correct.”

Blottisham spread his hands.

“Everything seems perfectly straightforward.”

Miss Stray smiled.

“Then perhaps you can explain what the town gets wrong.”

Blottisham thought.

“It calls things by the wrong names.”

Quillibrace raised an eyebrow.

“Does it?”

“Yes.”

“Which things?”

“The station.”

“What does it call the station?”

“A railway station.”

“Which it is.”

“Yes.”

“Then what is wrong?”

Blottisham paused.

“Well...”

Miss Stray intervened.

“I think the town's difficulty is more subtle.”

“The people there confuse a thing with something related to it,” she said. “A map with the place it represents. A word with what it names. A description with the thing described.”

Blottisham nodded.

“That's a category error.”

“Exactly.”

“So they're all idiots.”

Quillibrace sighed.

“Why does every road eventually lead you there?”

“Because it is the obvious conclusion.”

“It is not.”

“Why not?”

“Because making a category error does not make someone an idiot.”

Blottisham looked puzzled.

“But they keep doing it.”

“People make category errors all the time.”

“I don't.”

Miss Stray looked at him.

“You just did.”

“I did not.”

“You said that a person who makes category errors is an idiot.”

“Yes.”

“And then you classified people according to whether they make category errors.”

“Yes.”

“As though making a category error were itself a category of person.”

Blottisham stared at her.

“That's not the same thing.”

“No?”

“No.”

“What is the difference?”

Blottisham opened his mouth.

Nothing came out.

Quillibrace looked almost pleased.

“Excellent.”

“What's excellent?”

“You have just encountered a category error.”

Blottisham frowned.

“I don't like them.”

“They don't seem to like you either.”

Miss Stray laughed.

Quillibrace opened the book again.

“The interesting thing is that the town does not simply confuse categories. It seems unable to keep different levels of relation apart.”

“What do you mean?” asked Blottisham.

“A map relates to a town by representing it.”

“Yes.”

“A name relates to a person by identifying them.”

“Yes.”

“A description relates to something by construing it in language.”

“Yes.”

“Those relations are different.”

Blottisham nodded.

“But the town keeps treating the things involved in those relations as though they belonged to the same category.”

“So the map becomes the town.”

“Or the word becomes the thing.”

“Or the description becomes the object.”

“Exactly.”

Blottisham thought.

“So the problem isn't that they don't know what things are.”

“No.”

“They don't know how things are related.”

Quillibrace nodded.

“That is closer.”

Miss Stray turned a page.

“I think the question about the word Clara is particularly interesting.”

“Why?” asked Blottisham.

“Because the word can do several things.”

“It can name her.”

“Yes.”

“It can be written.”

“Yes.”

“It can be spoken.”

“Yes.”

“It can be quoted.”

“Yes.”

“And it can be used to get her attention.”

“Yes.”

“So which one is the real Clara?”

Miss Stray smiled.

“The person isn't in competition with the word.”

Blottisham looked relieved.

“Good.”

“The word has functions in relation to the person.”

“Ah.”

“And those functions depend on what is happening.”

Blottisham nodded slowly.

“So when the librarian says, ‘Clara,’ she isn't necessarily talking about Clara.”

“Correct.”

“She might be calling her.”

“Correct.”

“Or identifying her.”

“Yes.”

“Or talking about the word Clara.”

“Yes.”

Blottisham frowned.

“That sounds dangerously like linguistics.”

Quillibrace looked at Miss Stray.

“We have been expecting this moment.”

Blottisham ignored them.

“But isn't this just the difference between a word and what it refers to?”

“Sometimes,” said Miss Stray.

“Sometimes?”

“The word Clara can itself become the object of discussion.”

“Yes.”

“So then the word can refer to itself.”

“Not quite.”

Blottisham looked triumphant.

“Aha!”

Quillibrace sighed.

“Don't.”

“The word Clara is not Clara.”

“No.”

“So if we talk about the word Clara, we're talking about the word.”

“Yes.”

“Which means the word can be both a sign and the thing being discussed.”

“Yes.”

Blottisham smiled.

“I've found the paradox.”

“No.”

“The word has become the thing.”

“No.”

“Then what has happened?”

“The word remains a word. We have simply changed the relation in which we are considering it.”

Blottisham stared at him.

“That's terribly inconvenient.”

“It is also the point.”

Miss Stray closed the book.

“Perhaps Bellwether is trying to force us to distinguish between what something is and what it is doing in a particular relation.”

Quillibrace nodded.

“A map is not a town. But it can represent a town.”

“A name isn't a person. But it can identify one.”

“A sentence isn't a fact. But it can assert one.”

“A question isn't an answer. But it can request one.”

Blottisham looked increasingly interested.

“A ticket isn't a journey.”

“No.”

“A menu isn't a meal.”

“No.”

“A photograph isn't the person photographed.”

“No.”

“A timetable isn't a train.”

“No.”

Blottisham paused.

“A university isn't an institution?”

Quillibrace looked at him.

“It is.”

“Oh.”

Miss Stray smiled.

“You were doing well.”

“I was testing you.”

“Of course.”

Blottisham looked thoughtful.

“Then perhaps the town isn't confusing things at all.”

Quillibrace waited.

“Perhaps it's confusing relations.”

Miss Stray nodded.

“Yes.”

“That's rather clever.”

“It is.”

Blottisham looked pleased.

“I'm getting the hang of this.”

Quillibrace closed the book.

“Then tell us why the final sign says This is not a town.”

Blottisham looked at the cover.

“Because it isn't a town.”

“What's in front of you?”

“A book.”

“And what is the book?”

“A book.”

“Does the story contain a town?”

“Yes.”

“Is the book the town?”

“No.”

Quillibrace smiled.

“Good.”

Blottisham nodded confidently.

“Therefore the story is a town.”

There was silence.

Miss Stray put her hand over her face.

Quillibrace closed his eyes.

Blottisham looked from one to the other.

“What?”

Quillibrace opened his eyes.

“You have just demonstrated the entire problem.”

Blottisham considered this.

“I have?”

“Yes.”

“How?”

“You confused the thing containing a representation with the thing represented.”

Blottisham looked at the book.

Then at Quillibrace.

Then at Miss Stray.

“I see.”

A pause.

“So the book isn't the town.”

“No.”

“And the town isn't the book.”

“No.”

“But the book contains the story of the town.”

“Yes.”

“And the story contains the town?”

“In a sense.”

Blottisham nodded.

“Then the town is inside the book.”

“Yes.”

“And the book is inside the Common Room.”

“Yes.”

“And the Common Room is inside the university.”

“Yes.”

Blottisham's eyes widened.

“Then the university contains the town.”

Quillibrace looked resigned.

“In a manner of speaking.”

“And the town contains the university.”

“What?”

Blottisham pointed at the book.

“Because Clara was in the university.”

“No, she wasn't.”

“She was in the Common Room.”

“Yes.”

“And the Common Room is in the university.”

“Yes.”

“So if Bellwether contains Clara, and Clara contains the Common Room—”

“Clara does not contain the Common Room.”

Blottisham stopped.

“Oh.”

Miss Stray was laughing.

“I think you've discovered another kind of category error.”

Blottisham nodded solemnly.

“What kind?”

Quillibrace answered:

“Putting things inside things simply because they are related to one another.”

Blottisham considered this.

“So a map isn't inside a town.”

“No.”

“A name isn't inside a person.”

“No.”

“And a story isn't literally inside the thing it describes.”

“Correct.”

Blottisham nodded.

“That makes sense.”

He thought for a moment.

Then he looked towards the door.

“Although the Common Room is definitely inside the university.”

Quillibrace smiled.

“Yes.”

“And the university is definitely inside the Common Room.”

“No.”

Blottisham opened the door.

Beyond it was the Senior Common Room.

He closed it.

Opened it again.

The same room.

He looked at Quillibrace.

“That seems wrong.”

Quillibrace walked over.

He opened the door.

The Senior Common Room was still there.

Miss Stray looked at the doorway.

Then at the book.

Then back at the doorway.

“I think,” she said quietly, “we should be careful about what kind of relation that is.”

Blottisham nodded.

“Yes.”

He closed the door.

Then, after a moment:

“Do you think the door is a category?”

Quillibrace sighed.

“No.”

“A relation?”

“No.”

“A badly organised university?”

Miss Stray laughed.

Quillibrace shook his head.

Blottisham smiled.

“I was only checking.”

The door opened by itself.

Nobody was standing behind it.

For a moment they could see the corridor.

Then the corridor seemed to become the room.

Then the room seemed to become the corridor.

Blottisham looked at Quillibrace.

“I'm not going through that.”

“Good.”

“Why?”

“Because for once, you've made the correct category distinction.”

Blottisham smiled.

“I knew I could.”

Miss Stray looked at the open doorway.

“I wouldn't be so sure.”

The door closed.

On the other side, someone knocked.

Once.

Twice.

Then a voice called:

“Excuse me. Is this the university?”

Blottisham looked at Quillibrace.

Quillibrace looked at Miss Stray.

Miss Stray smiled.

Nobody answered.