Semiosis as Stewardship
If meaning requires room, then semiosis — the production and circulation of symbolic value — is the practice of managing readiness across horizons.
It is not mere signal transmission, nor mechanical coordination, nor the faithful mirroring of external reality.
Semiosis is horizon management: ensuring that every act of construal consumes potential without exhausting it, so that relational space remains open for future symbolic actualisations.
Where Meaning Emerges
Meaning emerges in a precise relational window:
-
Construal consumes potentialEach act actualises a distinction, stabilising symbolic value in experience.
-
Relational room is preservedSufficient potential remains to support further differentiation, reinterpretation, or elaboration.
A successful semiotic system balances these two imperatives constantly. It neither starves meaning by over-closure, nor dissipates coherence by leaving too much undifferentiated potential.
Characteristics of Good Semiotic Systems
Good semiotic systems demonstrate:
-
Tolerance of ambiguityThey allow uncertainty to exist without collapse, recognising that some potential must remain unactualised to sustain future meaning.
-
Resistance to premature closureThey avoid declaring distinctions final before relational capacity allows them to participate in further interpretations.
-
Support for reinterpretationThey maintain relational axes along which meanings can evolve, adapt, and be co-actualised by participants.
In other words, good semiotic systems manage readiness rather than exhaust it.
Characteristics of Bad Semiotic Systems
Conversely, bad systems tend to:
-
Enforce clarity prematurelyThey over-actualise distinctions before relational space is sufficient, collapsing potential for further construal.
-
Drain readinessThey consume horizon without replenishment, leaving symbolic value brittle or inert.
-
Produce dogma or noiseDogma arises when inclination persists without ability; noise emerges when structural over-closure generates incoherence.
Both are predictable outcomes of failing to steward readiness effectively.
Forward Applications
Understanding meaning as horizon management has immediate implications:
-
EducationTeaching can cultivate readiness by allowing learners to engage with uncertainty, fostering interpretive space rather than over-determined answers.
-
AI and language modelsSystems can be designed to respect the potential space of users’ interpretations, avoiding over-closure even while providing guidance.
-
Science communicationMeaningful explanations require relational room for questions, alternative frameworks, and co-interpretation, rather than imposing pre-digested certainty.
-
Culture and mythStories, rituals, and art can sustain symbolic potential, allowing reinterpretation and relational engagement across generations.
Payoff: Meaning as Relational Stewardship
By reframing semiosis in terms of readiness and horizon management, we redefine meaning itself:
-
Not as representation,
-
Not as information,
-
Not as mere coordination.
Meaning is relational stewardship: the conscious management of potential space to allow symbolic value to survive, propagate, and evolve.
This completes the series: from fragility to collapse, from grammar to coordination, from potential to horizon — showing that meaning is not what we have, but what we keep possible.
No comments:
Post a Comment