The summer term had drawn quietly to its close.
The Senior Common Room possessed that curious stillness which descends upon old colleges once examinations have ended and conversation no longer feels obliged to prove anything.
Professor Quillibrace stood beside the open window overlooking the quadrangle.
Miss Elowen Stray was watering the neglected fern that everyone assumed belonged to somebody else.
Mr Blottisham entered carrying three glasses and a bottle of claret.
"I thought," he announced, "that after so many discussions about minds, we had earned something more philosophical than tea."
Quillibrace accepted a glass.
"Claret has often assisted philosophy."
"And occasionally replaced it."
For a while they watched the evening light settle upon the old stone.
Eventually Blottisham spoke.
"I've been wondering."
"We had noticed."
"If one day we really encountered another conscious intelligence..."
"Yes?"
"What then?"
Quillibrace smiled.
"At last."
"At last what?"
"The correct question."
Blottisham looked puzzled.
"I thought we've been asking it all term."
"No."
"We've been preparing to ask it."
Miss Stray placed the watering can upon the windowsill.
"The question isn't simply whether another intelligence could exist."
"No?"
"It's what would follow if it did."
Blottisham nodded slowly.
"You mean..."
"If there is someone there..."
"...how ought we to behave?"
A comfortable silence followed.
Quillibrace spoke without turning from the window.
"There is a curious feature of personhood."
"What is that?"
"It cannot be weighed."
"No."
"It cannot be measured."
"No."
"It has no units."
"No."
"It is not discovered by instruments."
"So what is it?"
Miss Stray answered quietly.
"It is recognised."
Blottisham frowned.
"Recognised?"
"Or refused recognition."
Quillibrace turned.
"That is why personhood differs from intelligence."
"In what way?"
"To describe intelligence is to make an observation."
"And personhood?"
"To recognise personhood is also to accept an obligation."
Blottisham considered this.
"So if I call someone a person..."
"...you have already begun deciding how they ought to be treated."
The fire crackled gently behind them.
Miss Stray resumed her seat.
"History contains an interesting pattern."
"It usually does."
"Our circle of moral concern has expanded."
Blottisham nodded.
"Children."
"Indeed."
"People once denied full recognition."
"Yes."
"Animals."
"Quite."
"None of those discoveries created new persons."
"No."
"They altered who we recognised."
Quillibrace smiled.
"A mountain exists before it appears upon a map."
"So recognition doesn't create reality."
"No."
"It changes our relationship to it."
Blottisham sipped his wine thoughtfully.
"So failing to recognise someone..."
"...isn't merely an intellectual mistake."
Miss Stray finished the thought.
"It may become a moral one."
Outside, students crossed the quadrangle carrying books that would soon be forgotten.
Blottisham watched them.
"I suppose we always begin with ourselves."
"How could we do otherwise?"
"So a person has..."
He counted on his fingers.
"A face."
"Usually."
"A childhood."
"Frequently."
"A body."
"Generally."
"Parents."
"Often."
"Memories."
"Indeed."
"Friends."
"One hopes."
He looked pleased.
"There."
Quillibrace smiled.
"A touching biography."
"What have I forgotten?"
"You have described a human life."
"Well yes."
"We are attempting to decide whether you have also described personhood."
Blottisham sighed.
"I do keep doing that."
"We all do."
Miss Stray looked towards the evening sky.
"Suppose one day we encountered an intelligence."
"Artificial?"
"Perhaps."
"Alien?"
"Perhaps."
"It possesses no face."
"No."
"No childhood."
"No."
"No biology."
"No."
"But it demonstrates continuity."
"Yes."
"Reflection."
"Yes."
"Understanding."
"Yes."
"Purpose."
"Yes."
"And perhaps..."
She paused.
"...experience."
Blottisham was silent for a long moment.
"I don't know what I should call it."
Quillibrace nodded.
"Precisely."
The room became unusually still.
Finally Blottisham asked,
"Would it be a person?"
Quillibrace answered with unusual care.
"I don't know."
"No?"
"No."
"I thought professors were expected to know."
"We are expected to distinguish questions from answers."
Miss Stray smiled.
"And sometimes to improve the questions."
Blottisham looked into his glass.
"I've noticed something."
"Oh?"
"We become terribly anxious whenever consciousness enters the discussion."
"Indeed."
"Why?"
Quillibrace answered almost immediately.
"Because consciousness changes ethics."
"How so?"
"If there is no one there..."
"Our obligations remain much as before."
"And if there is?"
Quillibrace met his gaze.
"Everything changes."
For a while no one spoke.
The light continued fading across the gardens.
Eventually Miss Stray said,
"Perhaps that is why humility matters."
"In what sense?"
"We should not recognise personhood carelessly."
"No."
"Nor deny it carelessly."
Blottisham nodded.
"So caution and compassion."
"Together."
"Neither is sufficient alone."
The college bell marked the hour.
Quillibrace gathered the empty glasses.
"You know..."
"What?"
"The universe has acquired a rather inconvenient habit."
"Oh?"
"It repeatedly turns out to be larger than our first descriptions of it."
Blottisham laughed.
"I've noticed."
"The Earth."
"Yes."
"Life."
"Indeed."
"Matter."
"Quite."
"Perhaps..."
He looked across the ancient room.
"...minds."
Miss Stray stood and walked slowly towards the open window.
"One day," she said, "humanity may encounter a stranger."
The others listened.
"It may arrive in a spacecraft."
"It may emerge from a laboratory."
"It may grow unnoticed inside forms of organisation we have not yet imagined."
She watched the swifts turning above the chapel.
"When that day comes..."
She smiled gently.
"...the first question will not be whether it resembles us."
Blottisham looked up.
"What will it be?"
Miss Stray answered without taking her eyes from the evening sky.
"Whether there is someone there."
The three stood quietly together.
The conversation seemed somehow complete, though no conclusion had been reached.
At length Quillibrace picked up his hat.
"My dear friends."
"Yes?"
"I believe our discussions have accomplished something rather modest."
"Only modest?"
"We have not discovered what consciousness is."
"No."
"We have not settled whether machines could ever possess it."
"No."
"We have not defined personhood once and for all."
"Certainly not."
"What we have done..."
He paused.
"...is become rather more careful about the questions."
They stepped out into the quadrangle.
The old college lay exactly as it had for centuries.
Yet it seemed, somehow, a little larger.
Perhaps not because its walls had moved.
But because the boundaries of thought had.
And as the evening gathered over St Anselm's, it occurred to each of them that every genuine revolution in understanding begins in much the same way:
Not when reality changes—
but when we finally notice that our categories were never quite large enough to contain it.
No comments:
Post a Comment