Setting: A dim seminar room that looks slightly too formal to exist in reality. A blackboard still faintly carries traces of diagrams that refuse to erase properly.
Professor Quillibrace
(looking at the blackboard as if mildly disappointed in it)
We begin, as always, with what should have ended decades ago: the assumption that naming a failure prevents it from reproducing.
Mr Blottisham
(nervously adjusting his notes, which appear to be annotated with underlines of increasing desperation)
I must object—surely some of these isms still have moral traction? Realism, for instance, at least tries to preserve—
Quillibrace
Interrupts gently, as one might stop a kettle from philosophising.
—preserve what? A stable world? A stable subject? A stable hope that stability is not itself a contingent achievement?
No, no. That is precisely the genre error we are diagnosing.
Miss Elowen Stray
(not looking up, as if tracking something only partially visible)
They don’t preserve reality. They preserve permission structures for what counts as reality.
That’s why they persist after collapse.
Blottisham
(paling slightly)
Permission structures? That sounds… administratively ominous.
Quillibrace
Almost kindly:
All ontology is administrative, Mr Blottisham. Some simply forget they are working in an office.
Blottisham
But Platonism—surely Platonism is different? It gives us something higher.
Quillibrace
Ah yes. The famous vertical rescue operation.
Platonism: where abstraction is mistaken for altitude.
It is not “higher,” Mr Blottisham. It is simply more stable under a very particular kind of constraint—namely, the refusal to admit it is also constrained.
Miss Stray
Softly:
It survives because it makes stability feel like discovery rather than maintenance.
Blottisham
So… none of it was real?
Quillibrace
Pauses.
That depends entirely on what you mean by “was,” “none,” and “real.”
So: yes, in the strongest possible sense.
Blottisham
(whispering to himself)
I feel as though the furniture has been removed from under my categories.
Miss Stray
You’ll get used to standing on the floor instead.
It’s just less ceremonially announced.
Quillibrace
(closing the blackboard with finality)
The Residual Isms are not errors.
They are habits of closure that outlive their justification conditions.
That is all.
For now.
Blottisham
For now?!
Quillibrace
Already halfway out the door:
Ontology is rarely punctual, Mr Blottisham.
(He exits. No one is entirely sure whether the door was real.)
Miss Stray
(after a pause)
He’s right, though.
About ontology being late.
That part is consistent.
Blottisham
I hate when he is right and disappears.
It feels irresponsible.
No comments:
Post a Comment