Managed Populations Scene V: On the Citizen Who Refuses the Script

The television is off. The room is unusually still. A letter lies open on the table — printed, not digital.

Blottisham (reading, puzzled):
This is absurd.

Elowen:
What is it?

Blottisham:
A constituent letter forwarded to the department. It refuses to answer the survey.

Quillibrace:
Refuses?

Blottisham:
Not angrily. Not theatrically. Simply declines to participate.

Elowen:
On what grounds?

Blottisham (reading aloud):
“I do not recognise the framing of the question, and therefore decline to select from the available options.”

(A small silence.)

---

I. The Disruption

Blottisham:
This is unhelpful.

Quillibrace:
In what sense?

Blottisham:
It yields no data.

Elowen (softly):
Exactly.

Quillibrace:
The managed population functions through legibility.
To be governed is to be rendered readable.

Blottisham:
Everyone is readable.

Quillibrace:
Only if they accept the grammar.

---

II. Outside the Frame

Elowen:
What does it mean not to recognise the framing?

Quillibrace:
It means declining the offered categories.

Not “support” or “oppose.”
Not “secure” or “unsafe.”
Not “urgent” or “irresponsible.”

Blottisham:
But those are the available positions!

Quillibrace:
Available, yes. Exhaustive, no.

Elowen:
So refusal is not apathy. It is non-alignment.

---

III. The Anxiety of Illegibility

Blottisham (uneasy):
Surely one citizen makes no difference.

Quillibrace:
Statistically, none.

Elowen:
Structurally?

Quillibrace:
Illegibility introduces noise.

Blottisham:
Noise is negligible.

Quillibrace:
Unless it spreads.

(Blottisham stiffens.)

Quillibrace:
Managed systems tolerate dissent. They absorb outrage. They metabolise crisis.

What they struggle with is refusal to play.

---

IV. The Quiet Power

Elowen:
But this person hasn’t proposed an alternative.

Quillibrace:
They need not. They have declined the premise.

Blottisham:
That is childish.

Quillibrace:
On the contrary. It is disciplined.

Elowen:
They’re not attacking the system. They’re stepping sideways.

Quillibrace:
Yes. And sideways movement is difficult to model.

---

V. Beyond Management

Blottisham (after a pause):
What happens to such a person?

Quillibrace:
Usually nothing. They are ignored.

Elowen:
And if many refuse?

(A longer silence.)

Quillibrace:
Then management must either expand the frame —
or expose its limits.

Blottisham:
You make it sound as though democracy depends on cooperation more than conviction.

Quillibrace:
It depends on participation within pre-structured options.

Elowen:
And when someone declines the options?

Quillibrace:
The system cannot easily distinguish between freedom and malfunction.

---

VI. The Final Turn

(Blottisham folds the letter carefully.)

Blottisham:
Surely this is marginal. Democracy is resilient.

Quillibrace:
Resilience is admirable.

Elowen:
But resilience to what?

(Quillibrace looks at her with faint approval.)

Quillibrace:
To dissent, certainly.
To crisis, demonstrably.
To outrage, effortlessly.

But the true test of a managed population is this:

Can it tolerate citizens who refuse to be managed —
without first redefining them as error?

(A silence that is not uncomfortable — merely uncontained.)

Blottisham (quietly):
And if it cannot?

Quillibrace:
Then we learn what democracy was treating citizens as all along.