This mini-guide distills the main lessons from our posts on instantiation, ladder logic, and the persistence of epistemic privilege.
1. Instantiation is perspectival, not sequential
-
Texts and instances do not climb a ladder toward system-level abstraction.
-
Each instance is a cut across semiotic potential, producing meaning in context.
2. Stratification is symbolic, not generative
-
Strata (phonology, lexicogrammar, semantics, context) realise each other, but do not themselves create meaning.
-
Treating all strata as “meaning-making” (Martin’s error) confuses stratification with semogenesis.
3. Ladders are optional, not necessary
-
Ladder logic emerges when epistemic authority is prioritised upstream, not from Halliday’s model.
-
It is portable, appearing even when stratified context or genre is rejected.
4. Epistemic awareness is crucial
-
Name the ladder when it appears.
-
Decide consciously whether to retain, relax, or collapse it.
-
Awareness preserves interpretive flexibility, analytic accountability, and pedagogical openness.
5. Pedagogy without ladders
-
Encourage instance-first observation.
-
Treat variation as informative, not deviant.
-
Let system-level abstractions be retrospective, accountable, and descriptive, not directive.
6. Perspective over trajectory
-
Semiotic potential unfolds relationally, probabilistically, and contextually.
-
Meaning emerges, it is not prescribed.
-
Stepping off the ladder allows analysis, pedagogy, and theory to respect the relational and perspectival nature of semiotic systems.
Bottom line: Ladders travel only because we allow them to. Recognising them is the first step toward responsible, flexible, and reflective semiotic practice.
No comments:
Post a Comment